www.francisboutle.co.uk/     Call Us:  +44 7772 312 665    Email Us:  info@francisboutle.co.uk

Quick Find:    
Book list
Art, architecture & media
Biography
Cornish/Kernewek
D.M. Thomas
Fire and police
First World War
Genealogy
History
Lesser used languages of Europe
Literary criticism
Music
Painting and its laws
Pioneering women
Plays
Poets
Politics
Revolutionary history
Traditions and customs
Travel
Extras
Awards
Downloads
Events
Excerpts
Forthcoming books
Lesser Used Languages of Europe
Out of print
Reviews
Webzine
Contact Us
Follow us
Twitter Logo

Facebook Logo
  Top » Catalog » Pages » Reviews
Manannan’s Cloak – a bilingual anthology of Manx Literature

Click here for more information about this book

Reviewed by Nicholas Ostler in Ogmios  no. 45, 1 August 2011 Endangered Languages Foundation

Manannan's cloak is of invisibility, and is traditionally provided by the mists that swirl round Ellan Vannin, the Isle of Man. This doughty work of selection - which is also a mighty labour of love, since the anthologist has translated over 100 pages of Manx into as many pages of English - will actually do more to celebrate Manx than shroud it in more secrecy. It dispels the mists, revealing something of the reality of life as lived in Man these past five centuries. One's own language gives a distinct flavour to literature, and not all of  that is lost in the (very necessary) translation.

The earliest records of a Celtic language in Man date from ca 600, and include the proper name MaqLeog "Son of the physician", which is still around as the popular surname Clague (and even Clegg!) The texts selected begin ca 1500, with the beginning of the  "Traditionary Ballad" - Coontey Jeh Ellan Vannin Ayns Arrane, which is more literally translated as "Account of the Isle of Man in a Song"; the start is all about St Patrick, and how he brought the blessings of Christianity to the island in place of the "heathen" (Anchristee) god Mannanan (sic: we learn early than the Manx - or more traditionally Manks - people prefer to stress the first syllable).

Like the other Celtic languages, Manx's literature is thereafter dominated by Christian devotions. This comes through in this anthology, and is a clear reflection of the only kind of cultural life which was available for (and hence valued by) largely illiterate folk for many centuries. However, this is not the exclusive tenor of the compositions which Carswell has collected and translated here: so besides Psalms, Gospels and "The Principles and Duties of Christianity - Coyrle Sodjeh" we have song after song, and ballad after ballad, many of which we learn to call 'carval'. There are reminiscences of sea-battles "Thurot & Elliot 1760", mythical arson "Fin & Oshin 1763", and other nautical adventures. There are lusty translations or adaptations of Paradise Lost and The Rubaiyyat of Omar Khayyam; there is a satire on Manx politics worked out as a re-telling of the Three Little Pigs - Ny Three Muckyn Beggey. (Money, it turns out, is just as destructive as a lot of huff and puff.)  Inevitably, there are also elegies for the Manx language
itself: but the context makes it clear that affection for the language has not been universal on the island. Life becomes a bit more prosaic after 1950: the proportion of verse falls, but reportage, journalism and novels (notably murder mysteries) all make an appearance. The publishing future looks full, and unpredictable.

The result, for the Manx-less reader, is a rapid course in the history and the distinctive world-view of the Manxman and Manxwoman (including a "Carval of Bad Women"), as well as a rapid practical introduction to the language: since all the text is translated line for line, those who know English and some form of Gaelic will find it fairly easy to pick out the language in its distinctive Angloid dressing.

As for the spelling system, it is clear that in the 19th century, it was hoped (even by the Manx grammarian and Bible-translator, John Kelly), that it would serve transitional literacy: learning to read in Manx would lead on to literacy and fluency in English, and so replace all need for Manx. In fact, although the decline of Manx in 19th and 20th centuries certainly did happen, this is now being partially reversed: sterling work goes on in a local Bunscoill Ghaelgach to give primary school children a firm grounding in the language; and the Angloid spelling conventions now serve to give Manx an identity distinct from the Gaelic of Scotland or Ireland.  Sebba 2000 is an interesting supplement to this book, in reconstructing some of the linguistic politics here.*

This book is a very fitting Manx member of Francis Boutle's sequence of anthologies of literature in the minority languages of Europe. We English are at last being shown some of the delights which have been going on beneath our raised noses for many centuries, and in a form which, while instructive to those of us who rely on a lingua franca, is also true to these peoples' own words.

*Mark Sebba, 2000, "Orthography as Literacy: how Manx was 'reduced to
writing'". Bath: FEL IV (Ostler & Rudes, ed.): pp. 63-70

Best Sellers
01.From Bow to Biennale
02.Shout Kernow
03.Cornwalls First Golden Age
04.Baggage
05.The Old Red Tongue
06.Grains of Gold
07.Celebrating Pevsner
08.Surfing Tommies
09.The Way Back
10.Scoot Dances
Forthcoming Books
Featured Books
Events
Regular Cornish language classes with Mick Paynter.

London. The Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Gallery permanent exhibition of women in medicine.

First Sunday of every month, Redruth. Shout with the Red River singers.

Second Wednesday of every month, Luxulyan. Prys Ton – Cornish Music Session.

5 July 2017, Cardiff. Reception for The Old Red Tongue an anthology of Welsh literature hosted by Open University Wales.

7 July 2017, Penzance. Alan M. Kent discusses hiw new book, Re-inventing Victorian Cornwall: Dan Daddow’s Cornish Comicalities.

8 July 2017, Builth Wells, Powys. Peter Brooke talk on British values and Free Trade.

13 July 2017, London. Cornish poetry pop-up event with poet Tim Saunders.

23 July 2017, Par, Cornwall. Pyba perform at Tywardreath Priory.

29–31 August 2017, East Sussex. Pyba at Herstmonceaux Medieval Festival.

1 September 2017, Launceston. Cornish Dance Society Ceilidh with Pyba.

10 September 2017, St Ives. Kemysk at St Ives September Festival.

6 October 2017, Aldeburgh. Elizabeth Garrett Anderson Commemoration Weekend with talks, a play, music and the unveiling of a plaque.